Green-Eyeshades Not Needed- Contractor Awarded Partial Fees in Partial Victory

National Law Review
AECOM was awarded $5.2 million in attorney's fees, a portion of the $12 million requested, following a partial victory against Exxon.

Summary

A Montana court awarded AECOM $5.2 million in attorney's fees after the contractor partially prevailed in a dispute with Exxon over work performed at a refinery in 2019. AECOM initially claimed $100 million for extra work, while Exxon counterclaimed for nearly $100 million. The jury awarded AECOM $64 million but also $20 million to Exxon, resulting in a net judgment of $44 million for AECOM.

The court applied the 'lodestar method' to determine reasonable attorney's fees, acknowledging the complexity of the case and the lack of local counsel with comparable experience. However, the award was reduced to 43% of the requested amount—reflecting AECOM’s partial success, as its recovery was 43% of the amount sought. The court specifically stated it would not act as “green-eyeshade accountants” in scrutinizing the fees.

AECOM’s requests for expert fees and e-discovery costs were denied, as the Montana lien statute only allows for the recovery of attorney’s fees, and AECOM did not prevail on its claim under the Montana Prompt Payment Act. The court ultimately adhered to the American Rule, preventing the shifting of these additional costs to Exxon.

(Source:National Law Review)

Netnewsledger

How Subscription Models Are Transforming Traditional B2B Services in 2026

Artificial Lawyer Legal Technology Blog

AI Benefits, Cooley’s Meatballs, Opus 2 +

Artificial Lawyer Legal Technology Blog

Law Firms Don’t Have an AI Problem, They Have a Data Problem

Singapore Law Watch

From Pain Points to Possibilities: Building Your Legaltech Toolkit · Luma

Complete Ai Training

Six major tech companies enter the legal AI market

Quartz

Fireworks AI raised $1.5 billion as companies flee costly AI for open-source alternatives

Business Standard

Vishwanand Srivastava, Founder & CEO of Caz Brain Group, Strengthens Caz Legal AI to Build AI-Enabled Legal Professionals

Finanznachrichten.de

Exterro, Inc.: Exterro's ARMOURop Delivers a Force Multiplier for Digital Forensic Labs, Slashing Evidence Review Time by Up to 95%

Insider

Harvey acquires Benchmark as it grows beyond the legal department

Insider

Parag Agrawal's Parallel partners with Google Cloud for AI tools

Artificial Lawyer Legal Technology Blog

Vanilla, Meatballs + Cooley’s Flat Fees – with David Wang

Newsbreak

Amazon Launches Quick for Legal AI Assistant for Contracts and Compliance - NewsBreak

Washingtontechnology

Veterans Affairs starts search for cloud-based litigation review platform

Complete Ai Training

AI adoption requires law firms to restructure workflows and governance

Legal Reader

Luminance Unveils ‘Luna Crescent’, the Vertical AI Model Powering Contract Intelligence with Market-leading Accuracy and Speed